Film review – A Prophet (2009)

Malik El Djebena (Tahar Rahim)

Malik El Djebena is a 19-year-old repeat offender who is thrown into a French prison to do six years for assaulting a policeman. As a non-religious Arab, Malik is shunned by both the Muslims and the Corsicans who both have a strong presence in the prison, locked in a long-running power struggle. Malik is illiterate, young, fragile and covered with bruises and scars from previous altercations. A Prophet’s shadowed and noisy opening thrusts Malik out of the darkness and into the harsh light of the prison in a way that suggests he is ‘born’ into the prison like a vulnerable child. Despite his chances of survival looking grim Malik soon takes his first steps in his transformation as a master criminal when the dominant Corsican prison gang force him to kill for them.

Directed and co-written by Jacques Audiard (The Beat That My Heart Skipped) A Prophet is essentially a gangster film with a number of distinguishing differences. For a start, Malik’s criminal ascent occurs while he is in prison but thanks to the corrupt networks within the prison, which also allow him the occasional day pass, he is able to operate successful activities in the outside world. Also, apart from his initial act of forced violence, Malik’s success is predominantly due to his studious self-education and cunning rather than displays of power and might.

Malik and Corsican prison gang leader César Luciani (Niels Arestrup)

A Prophet’s social realism style separates it from the more traditionally glamorous or sensationalist gangster films so that its portrayal of somebody marginalised by French society becoming indoctrinated into criminality functions as a genuine social critique of both the prison system and prejudices within France. However, A Prophet also contains several effective non-realistic touches that border on surrealism, which clearly identifies it as a work of fiction as opposed to the cold reality of organised crime that is represented in the equally excellent Italian film Gomorrah.

A Prophet is an extremely gripping and exciting film. The scenes leading up to moments of violence are incredibly tense and even through we know what is about to happen, the violence in this film is genuinely shocking. The almost-unknown actor Tahar Rahim portrays Malik as a likeable yet unsettling anti-hero and his transformation from a virtual child to a gangster is convincing and frightening.

© Thomas Caldwell, 2010

Bookmark and Share

Read more reviews at MRQE


  1. Aw gee, Thomas, you’re giving it away [CINEMA AUTOPSY EDIT]. I think part of the joy of this amazing film is not knowing where it’s going, and discovering how it gets there.

  2. Fair enough Paul. Maybe I’m so familiar with the genre that I didn’t even consider that to be something that could be regarded as a spoiler. I found it clear from the beginning where it was going but enjoyed it for how it got there.

    Anyway, I’ve edited my review (and your comment!) so that nothing is given away.


  3. I don’t believe Malik is part Corsican (he speaks Arabic but has to learn Corsican privately to deceive the Corsicans into continually speaking freely in front of him).

    Malik is a young French Arab that isn’t singularly a part of the Arab community in the prison because he doesn’t identify with being a devout Muslim as many of the other Arab inmates do. He also does not look particularly Arab making it easy for him to blend in with either group that is convenient.

  4. Karen, you are absolutely right and I’ve changed my review accordingly. I don’t know why I initially read it that way when it is so clearly incorrect. Thanks for pointing that error out and explaining it so concisely.

    Wow, getting a key fact wrong and dropping a major spoiler – I really was in very poor form when I wrote this review!

Comments are closed.